Now Reading
When passive investing in Philippine stocks stops making sense
Dark Light

When passive investing in Philippine stocks stops making sense

An index fund that tracks the Philippine Stock Exchange Index (PSEi) is a sensible tool, but it is neither as diversified nor as safe as it sounds. Buying “the whole market” works best when the market is broad, cheap to trade and unrelated to the rest of your life.

The Philippine market fails on all three counts more often than investors realize.

This note sets out seven ways passive local investing can stop serving you. None is a reason to avoid PSEi altogether. Each is a reason not to treat it as your only equity holding.

1. A 30-stock basket is not ‘the market’

PSEi holds just 30 companies, and a few family-controlled groups carry much of the weight. Owning the index means owning a large bet on those groups, not a slice of the whole economy.

The concentration is deeper than it looks. Parent holding companies and their listed subsidiaries both sit in the index: SM Investments Corp. besides SM Prime Holdings and BDO Unibank; Ayala Corp. besides Ayala Land and Bank of the Philippine Islands.

You end up owning the same businesses twice.

The mix is lopsided too. Property, banks, holding firms and domestic consumer names dominate, while exporters, healthcare and technology barely feature. When property and lending suffer together, as they have since interest rates rose and office demand fell, there is little in the index to soften the blow.

2. Costs that you don’t see on the fact sheet

Many index stocks trade thinly, and a large share of their shares is locked up with controlling owners. Thin trading makes prices jumpy when big orders arrive.

Index changes are announced before they take effect. Insiders buy stocks about to join the index and sell those about to leave, so index funds tend to buy high and sell low at each review.

That cost never appears in the expense ratio, but it comes out of your return all the same.

3. Our market leaves money on the table

The classic case for index funds comes from big, heavily researched markets like the United States, where mispriced stocks are rare. The Philippine market is different: few analysts cover it, and bargains can sit unnoticed for months.

That means careful stock-picking can genuinely add value here. Passive investing is still the right call for some, but for a practical reason: active managers with absolute return targets are hard to come by. If you have access to one at a fair fee, or the skill and time to research stocks yourself, an index or passive fund gives up a real advantage.

4. You can’t avoid the bad actors

Most listed Philippine companies are run by controlling families, and minority shareholders do not always get a fair deal. Common problems include deals with related companies, share sales that dilute small holders and buyouts to take a company private at a low price.

Those buyouts tend to come when share prices are depressed, which is exactly when future returns look best. An absolute return manager can avoid PSEi companies with poor records. An index fund must hold whatever is in the index, on whatever terms the controlling owners set.

5. You already own plenty of the Philippines

This is the most important point and the one most often missed. Your salary or business income, your home, your pension and your family’s prospects all depend on the Philippine economy and the peso.

In a bad year, these tend to fall together. Jobs become less secure, property prices soften, the peso weakens and local stocks drop. A portfolio full of PSEi shares then falls just when you most need it to hold up.

Prudent investing adds assets that do well when the rest of your life is under strain. For a Filipino, that usually means owning the good companies, not more bad ones.

6. The peso and the price of staying home

Over long periods, the peso has tended to lose value against the dollar. Many things Filipinos pay for, from fuel and gadgets to overseas tuition and travel, track the dollar more than the peso. Holding some dollar assets protects your purchasing power.

There is also the cost of what you missed. PSEi has gone roughly nowhere in price for over a decade, while global markets have grown substantially.

An index fund will never tell you to reconsider; that decision is yours to make.

See Also

7. Price and patience both matter

A cheap market tends to deliver better returns later, and PSEi trades at much lower multiples than in its mid-2010s peak. That case only works if you can wait many, many years for prices to recover.

Money you will need sooner, for a house down payment or school fees, does not belong in the bad stocks at all. And buying the index regardless of price throws away the very advantage that makes the good stocks attractive today: a low starting valuation.

What a sensible approach looks like

A low-cost PSEi index fund or exchange traded funded can earn its place as one part of a portfolio. It works best when bought steadily over time, held for many, many years and balanced with foreign investments.

Before relying on it, ask yourself:

• Is PSEi only part of my stock holdings, not all of them?

• Do I also own some foreign shares or dollar assets?

• Can I leave this money untouched for a decade?

• Am I paying low fees, ideally under 0.50 percent a year?

• Am I buying because the 30 companies are creating value for me, a minority shareholder, not simply because PSEi feels familiar?

If you answered no to several of these, passive local investing may be doing less for you than you think.

Have problems with your subscription? Contact us via
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
Landline: (02) 8896-6000
SMS/Viber: 0908-8966000, 0919-0838000

© 2025 Inquirer Interactive, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.

Scroll To Top