Big questions on the Mactan-Cebu airport
After I questioned the planned privatization of our country’s air navigation services in my op-ed entitled “Review privatization policy” last week, a concerned citizen pointed to another multibillion-peso government project which raises plenty of questions. The worried citizen sent news materials about an impending 25-year extension of a private consortium’s concession agreement to manage and operate the Mactan-Cebu International Airport (MCIA).
By way of background, in 2014, a 25-year concession agreement to operate the old MCIA was awarded to GMR Megawide Cebu Airport Corp. (GMCAC). The winning concessionaire paid P14.4 billion to the government and, in return, it gained the right to operate the airport, and thereby collect fees and earn from a variety of income streams. Pursuant to its contract, GMCAC was obliged to renovate and expand the existing passenger terminal, build a second terminal, provide parking space, and develop commercial spaces around the airport premises.
In 2024, a new company called Aboitiz InfraCapital bought out GMCAC and became the new operator of MCIA. Now comes news that the new airport operator is about to be given a 25-year extension of the original concession agreement, after it reportedly committed P15 billion in capacity augmentation and capital investments. Since the original 25-year concession agreement is yet to expire in 2039, any 25-year extension will give Aboitiz InfraCapital until 2064 to operate the airport and collect a basket of revenues.
The first question is: Why is the government awarding an extension when the original concession agreement still has a life of 13 years before it expires? Why is the government in such a hurry to “extend” the concession agreement?
The second question is: Why is the government calling the agreement an “extension” when it’s clearly a second 25-year concession agreement on top of the original 25-year concession agreement? An extension agreement would be for a period of less than the term of the original agreement. A new agreement for the same term as the old agreement is a renewal of the contract, in this case a renewal of the concession agreement. A renewed concession agreement is a second concession agreement.
The third question is: Why is the government awarding a second concession agreement without mandatory public bidding? From news releases, the supposed approval to extend the concession agreement was reached without any mention of any bidding process, a winning bidder, and losing bidders. Without public bidding, how can the government ensure that it’s getting the best terms offered by multiple competing parties?
The fourth question is: Are the government and Aboitiz unaware of the Piatco case (Agan Jr. v. Philippine International Air Terminals Co., Inc.), which was a landmark case decided way back in 2003? In the said case, the Supreme Court declared as null and void the build-operate-transfer concession agreement over the Ninoy Aquino International Airport Terminal III (Naia III). Among other reasons, the Naia III concession agreement was nullified because of substantial alterations or amendments to the contract originally presented to all bidders. Under public bidding rules, changing terms and conditions after the bid award invalidates the contract because it undermines fair competition and turns the concession agreement into an entirely different contract.
In the case of the “extended” concession agreement of Aboitiz InfraCapital over MCIA, it not only alters or amends the original contract but totally renews the contract for a new term of 25 years. It’s an entirely different contract per the yardstick of Piatco.
If Aboitiz InfraCapital gets its way by having another 25-year concession agreement over MCIA, it will have gained a 40-year monopoly of business revenues in the airport since 2024. Is that beneficial to the public?
The underlying objective of a concession agreement granted to private business is to tap private capital to build capital-intensive public infrastructure and allow the concessionaire to earn income on top of recovering its investment for a period that’s usually 25 years. During the concession period, the public pays relatively higher fees for the use of the structure. After the concession period expires, however, the government is supposed to take over, perform the maintenance and refurbishment responsibilities, so that the public can already enjoy paying lower charges. Moreover, when the government takes over high-traffic and monopoly infrastructure like our major airports, it will start earning the billions in yearly revenues that used to go to the private concessionaire.
But how will the public benefit from lower charges and how will the government earn billions in revenues if it unendingly bequeaths to private companies our crown jewels?
In 2014, a group of concerned Cebuanos went to the Supreme Court to try to stop the award of the original concession agreement over the MCIA. They lost. They may have better luck the second time around.
—————-
Comments to [email protected]
