Now Reading
Pax and process
Dark Light

Pax and process

Anna Cristina Tuazon

The attention toward the proposed Pax Silica hub reaches its peak as the 49th Asean Summit brings sovereign leaders, including the president of the United States, whose country is leading the initiative to our shores. One cannot fault environmental and indigenous rights advocates and activists for grabbing this prime opportunity to get their message across, especially as our government had been reticent to hold genuine public dialogue and consultations about the proposal.

I won’t pretend to know the subject matter intimately well. I only know what has been officially released to the public, which is, let’s admit it, not much. With any big project that has potentially far-reaching consequences, both good and bad, I’d like to offer some basic ground rules that will allow us to consider this project mindfully and wisely.

1. Do not rush the process.

The bigger and more complex the undertaking, the more important it becomes to ensure that everything has been thought through. Rushing is the opposite of being mindful and wise. Rushing means we are more likely to react and act on impulse, increasing the likelihood of making mistakes. In big commitments like the ones that Pax Silica requires, mistakes can be irreversible. We also need to be mindful of the forces that are encouraging the rush. Anyone who tries to rush you into signing a contract is someone who does not wish for you to scrutinize the fine print.

2. Transparency above all else.

It is only when everything is transparent that we can make an informed decision. This is one of the major frustrations about Pax Silica and the proposed hub in New Clark City: a terrible lack of transparency. Transparency means that we know all the details of the project. We should know its scope and limitations. We should know all the parties involved. We should know how many resources it will require and how much will be taken from communities. It doesn’t help that the declared scope of the hub seems to change depending on who is asking and who is being asked. Will there be an artificial intelligence data center or not? Will it take water from us or not? Did the United States request jurisdiction over the zone or not? Will there be significant technology transfer or are we merely being used for cheap resources and labor? Who will bear responsibility for any environmental consequences incurred by the hub?

Transparency is both action and a virtue. Transparency should be evident in the government’s actions and how it prioritizes relaying information to its constituents. Moreover, transparency as an action also requires that the government actively seeks feedback and inputs from the community. Transparency can also be treated as a virtue. A government that values transparency is a government that respects its constituents, including their grievances and concerns. Transparency treats constituents as stakeholders and partners instead of beneficiaries or, at worst, collateral damage.

Imagine any relationship that does not value transparency—it is a relationship filled with secrets. It could mean that there are things that we know to be unpalatable to others, hence why we hide them. Low transparency could also mean not trusting their capacity to comprehend and understand and thinking we are better off making decisions for them. Either reasoning shows a lack of respect for the other’s agency.

3. Discern what is written on paper vs. what is happening on the ground.

The trouble with bureaucracy is that what starts out as a beautifully written policy can get diluted into something unrecognizable by the time it reaches communities. Whenever we do community-based research, we often find a disconnect between what is shared by central government agencies, which tout their programs, and by community workers, who most likely have never even heard of them.

See Also

The Pax Silica initiative and the proposed hub make big promises regarding jobs, industry, and the economy. As they say, however, the devil is in the details. What is the track record of these promise-makers—have they followed through? Do they leave a trail of thriving, happy communities in their wake? What is our own government’s track record when it comes to protecting our environment and our indigenous communities? If we cannot protect them from our own citizens and leaders, how do we expect to protect them from global superpowers?

We might get distracted by the promised outcomes. Who wouldn’t want better-paying jobs? Who wouldn’t want us to grow and evolve our industrial capabilities? However, what they’re proposing is not the outcome but the “how.” Our conversations need to be about the “how”: How do we create jobs and industries without sacrificing our environment and communities? How do we grow our economy without risking our sovereignty? Promises are easily made; how promises get delivered is more important.

—————-

[email protected]

Have problems with your subscription? Contact us via
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
Landline: (02) 8896-6000
SMS/Viber: 0908-8966000, 0919-0838000

© 2025 Inquirer Interactive, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.

Scroll To Top