Scrutinizing BIR shakedowns
In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes.”
For most Filipinos, one could easily lead to the other, as being subjected to what many consider as extortionate tax audits by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), has left small businesses and taxpayers flailing for survival.
Following reports of excessive fees collected by the BIR and the Bureau of Customs (BOC), the Ombudsman has ordered an intensified lifestyle check on the two agencies’ officials and employees. “[S]ome collectors take from businesses more than what is allowed by law … with no receipts [issued],” Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla said, adding this is “corruption.”
Remulla said the anti-graft office will closely monitor the assets, houses, vehicles, and travel records of BIR and BOC personnel identified as “notorious” in alleged extortion and overcharging schemes.
In September this year, Sen. Bam Aquino called for fair and transparent BIR tax audits, and for the agency to strengthen its safeguards against bribery, corruption, and abuse, particularly to protect micro, small, and medium enterprises.
Letter of authority
At a Senate budget hearing in November last year, Sen. Erwin Tulfo and Sen. JV Ejercito exposed the alleged corruption of errant personnel using the BIR’s letter of authority (LOA), and pocketing up to 70 percent of revenue collections.
“If the DPWH has flood control projects, the BIR has what they call the LOA,” Tulfo said.
The scheme targets single proprietorships, which are issued LOAs repeatedly. “Of course, they don’t want the hassle, so they’d rather just settle. Because even if they’ve paid everything completely and have receipts for all of it, some BIR inspectors—the examiners—will keep looking for faults … Sometimes they even backtrack 5 to 6 years. Where are [taxpayers] supposed to find those documents?” the senator pointed out.
Indeed, a businesswoman at the Senate hearing spoke of how, after settling an LOA to avoid any trouble, she became a “suki,” a regular target for the BIR despite LOAs supposedly being issued at random. How easy it is to milk small taxpayers forced into compliance simply because they can’t afford lawyers to navigate the complex taxation process!
Unexplained wealth
One condominium source meanwhile questioned why the BIR has been issuing the condo corporation LOAs for years now, with outrageously high valuation when the property is strictly residential and has no commercial business in the premises. The homeowners’ dues cover maintenance, staff wages, and administrative costs and should not be considered as income, the source added.
The stricter lifestyle check should thus be a timely reminder to government officials and employees that, aside from the mandatory filing of their sworn statement of assets, liabilities, and net worth as mandated by the Constitution, they are expected to live simply and within their means, as a lavish lifestyle invites suspicions on how the extra funds were sourced.
This is exactly the point that prosecutors at the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte are trying to make in questioning the over P256,882 that her husband, Manases Carpio, had spent on basketball shoes for a young team in Davao. Sen. Pia Cayetano may bray all she wants about how the scrutiny over the rubber shoes betrays a lack of support for sports, but the core message here is that public officials, no matter their post and the millions of votes they got, are subject to accountability, especially when faced with charges of unexplained wealth.
Human discretion
In the same manner, BIR agents must be ready to account for how they conduct tax audits using LOAs to preclude complaints of abuse, harassment, and corruption. While then BIR Commissioner Charlito Martin Mendoza has said that many BIR personnel are being investigated, with some formally charged for abuses, Tulfo urged the official to consider reshuffling regional directors who, over time, may have learned to tolerate or themselves have benefited from systemic moneymaking schemes.
Aquino’s proposed BIR reforms bear serious consideration as well. The senator called for the removal of independent audit selection powers from individual revenue district offices to prevent selective targeting and favoritism. A truly random manual or automated audit selection system can reduce human discretion and corruption risks.
The BIR should also publicly release all LOAs so business owners can verify whether an audit order is legitimate, or if it involves fake or unrecorded demands. A three- to five-year shield against LOAs issued repeatedly could also prevent arbitrary and overlapping audits. As well, the Ombudsman’s planned Philippine Regulatory Summit in 2027 could eliminate policy gaps and complicated rules that breed fixers.
Finally, can the BIR simplify and explain the tax forms and collection process so taxpayers would at least know for certain if they’re being bilked, and act accordingly?
