The 11 first-time winners of the Emmys
The 2025 Primetime Emmy Awards held on Sept. 14 was a night of triumph for television’s many talented actors. Yet no one onstage shone quite as bright as the ceremony’s first-time acting winners, who represent the growing diversity and talent in television.
From 15-year-old newcomer Owen Cooper’s breakthrough in “Adolescence” to medical TV drama veteran Noah Wyle’s return to TV in “The Pitt,” this year’s Emmys prove that a career-defining performance can never happen too late or too early.
Cristin Milioti: Outstanding Actress in a Limited Series or Movie (“The Penguin”)
After multiple scene-stealing moments in “How I Met Your Mother” and “Made For Love,” Cristin Milioti gained her Emmy-winning performance from “The Penguin.” Her transformation as the volatile yet calculating Sofia Falcone in “The Batman” (2022) spin-off showcased her acting range, proving she could command a series with the same magnetic presence that made her a fan favorite in her previous work.
Britt Lower: Outstanding Actress in a Drama Series (“Severance”)
Britt Lower’s multi-layered performance in the psychological thriller “Severance” captivated audiences with its exploration of work-life balance, identity, and corporate ethics. Her ability to play two distinct versions of the same character, Helly R. in Lumon Industries and Helena Eagan in the outside world, demonstrated masterful acting that viewers just couldn’t ignore.
Stephen Graham: Outstanding Actor in a Limited Series or Movie (“Adolescence”)
An accomplished British actor known for his roles in “Boardwalk Empire” and the sixth season of “Peaky Blinders,” Stephen Graham finally claimed his first Emmy with “Adolescence,” which he also co-wrote and produced. His winning lead performance as Eddie Miller, the father of a 13-year-old boy suspected of murdering a female classmate, highlighted his intense yet naturalistic acting style.
Noah Wyle: Outstanding Actor in a Drama Series (“The Pitt”)
Noah Wyle’s return to television medical drama as the world-weary Dr. Robby Robinavitch of “The Pitt,” which also won the award for Outstanding Drama Series, reminded everyone why he was such a compelling presence in the genre. The longtime actor finally earned his first Emmy after five consecutive nominations for his performance as the idealistic Dr. John Carter of “ER.”
Seth Rogen: Outstanding Actor in a Comedy Series (“The Studio”)
Known primarily for his comedic roles in films such as “Knocked Up,” “Funny People,” and “Superbad,” Seth Rogen took home his first Emmy for his portrayal of the conflicted head of Continental Studios in “The Studio.” The mockumentary series, which Rogen also wrote, produced, and directed, showcased his ability to put a satirical spin on the very industry that made him famous.
Erin Doherty: Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Limited Series or Movie (“Adolescence”)
British actress Erin Doherty, who gained recognition for her role as Princess Anne in “The Crown,” proved her versatility as Briony Ariston in “Adolescence.” Her shift from a no-nonsense English royal to a suspicious yet cautiously hopeful child psychologist demonstrated her ability to disappear completely into a role, showing audiences why she’s considered one of the UK’s most promising talents.
Katherine LaNasa: Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series (“The Pitt”)
An onscreen veteran with multiple roles spanning television and film, Katherine LaNasa finally received her Emmy recognition as Dana Evans in “The Pitt.” Her performance as the compassionate yet tough-as-nails charge nurse of an overcrowded and underfunded ER underscored the harsh reality most public health workers must face, resonating with audiences and critics alike.
Hannah Einbinder: Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series (“Hacks”)
Despite being the daughter of renowned comedian Laraine Newman, Hanah Einbinder managed to carve out her own path to Emmy gold with the dark comedy series “Hacks.” Her chemistry with Jean Smart (who won her seventh Emmy this year) and her authentic portrayal of the struggling comedy writer Ava Daniels made for an award-winning combination.
Tramell Tillman: Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series (“Severance”)
Tramell Tillman’s performance as Seth Milchick in “Severance” gave viewers one of television’s most unnerving characters. His ability to be simultaneously amiable and menacing made him an essential part of the show’s appeal. Tillman also made history as the first Black and gay man to win the supporting actor award.
Owen Cooper: Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie (“Adolescence”)
New British talent Owen Cooper showcased his ability to hold his own alongside seasoned actors, like fellow Emmy winners Stephen Graham and Erin Doherty, as Jamie Miller of “Adolescence.” His portrayal of a troubled pre-teen boy suspected of murder not only earned him recognition as the youngest Emmy winner at 15 years old but also proved that the best performers are often the ones you least expect.
Jeff Hiller: Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series (“Somebody Somewhere”)
Jeff Hiller’s heartwarming performance as Joel in “Somebody Somewhere” brought much-needed small-town queer representation and authenticity to the television comedy-dramas of today. Hiller managed to bring equal parts depth and humor to the simple yet heartfelt series, which follows a 40-year-old woman’s return to her hometown in Kansas upon the death of her sister, making his Emmy win feel just as meaningful.
