10 years on: South Africa debates letting go of Mandela

(FILES) A picture taken on December 6, 2018 shows an oil painting of former South African president and Anti Apartheid icon Nelson Mandela on the first floor of the Rand Club in Johannesburg. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by MARCO LONGARI / AFP)

(FILES) People celebrate as the funeral cortege of South African former president Nelson Mandela drives to the Union Buildings for the lying in state on December 12, 2013 in Pretoria. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by Marco LONGARI / AFP)

(FILES) A woman walks past a portrait of late South African President Nelson Mandela in Soweto on December 10, 2013. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by Filippo MONTEFORTE / AFP)

(FILES) A sign in Durban presents a message in Zulu reading “Farewell, Father”, in honor of late former South African President Nelson Mandela, on the day of Mandela’s burial in his hometown of Qunu, on December 15, 2013. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by ANESH DEBIKY / AFP)

(FILES) Residents walk past murals of late South African former president Nelson Mandela in Soweto, near Johannesburg, on December 7, 2013, two days after his death. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by Carl DE SOUZA / AFP)

(FILES) A laser image of late former South African President Nelson Mandela’s face and his clan name “Madiba” is projected on the Table Mountain in Cape Town, late on December 10, 2013. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by Jennifer BRUCE / AFP)

(FILES) A learner from Northlen Primary school places on the chalkboard posters of former president Nelson Mandela as they mark his birthday in Durban on July 18, 2019. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by RAJESH JANTILAL / AFP)

(FILES) Learners from Northlen Primary school colour drawings of former president Nelson Mandela as they mark his birthday in Durban on July 18, 2019. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by RAJESH JANTILAL / AFP)

(FILES) A picture of anti-apartheid icon, Nelson Mandela, is displayed inside the gym at the Young Men Christian Association (YMCA) in Soweto on July 11, 2018 where Nelson Mandela used to train in the 1950’s. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by Wikus DE WET / AFP)

(FILES) People sing to pay a tribute to late former South African president Nelson Mandela outside his former house in Soweto on December 6, 2013. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by STEPHANE DE SAKUTIN / AFP)

(FILES) The president of the African National Congress (ANC), Nelson Mandela gives a clenched fist to supporters upon his arrival for an election rally on gives March 15, 1994 in Mmabatho. democratic and multiracial general elections. Anti-apartheid hero Nelson Mandela has been seen as a moral compass in his home South Africa, but ten years after his death his legacy is vigorously debated, with some questioning the quality of the country’s democracy. (Photo by WALTER DHLADHLA / AFP)

JOHANNESBURG—Ten years after the death of Nelson Mandela, the fabled destroyer of apartheid remains a global icon, but in South Africa some say it is time to end Mandela-mania. A 9-meter tall statue of Mandela, his arms outstretched, watches over Pretoria from the Union Buildings government headquarters.

There are at least 50 other major statues, busts and murals devoted to him in South Africa and around the world, from London to the occupied West Bank, according to the Mandela Foundation.

Mandela, who died on Dec. 5, 2013, is featured on national banknotes and his “Long Walk To Freedom” autobiography remains one of the best-selling books worldwide of all time.

Robben Island, Mandela’s jail for 27 years, is among South Africa’s top tourist attractions.

The standing of the political giant, widely known by his clan name of “Madiba,” is so great that many people watching the sorry state of South Africa’s economy and politics ask “what would Madiba think if he were still here.”

Would events have been different?

Spurring South Africans to move on, the foundation on Friday opened an anniversary exhibition called simply and soberly “Mandela is Dead.”

‘Destructive energy’Any country with such a strong figure suffers for many years after the personality is gone from the “deep nostalgia and this hanging on to that symbol,” said Verne Harris, the late president’s archivist and acting president of the Mandela Foundation.

“What we are saying in this exhibition, is that maybe that becomes a destructive energy. Maybe we need to let him go. And look for new role models.”

The exhibition presentation highlights “the weight of the loss we suffered” with Mandela’s death.

As part of its efforts to help “process this grief”, it features interactive displays that encourage visitors to say what they think about Mandela’s heritage.

Message boards were put up at two universities for comments. Some of the responses are startling and highlight divisions over Mandela’s legacy.

Left-wing parties and many youth say the late leader should have done more to dismantle the effects of apartheid’s nearly five decades of institutionalized discrimination by the white minority that tore apart society.

“His legacy has done nothing but keep the poor poor and the rich rich, freedom is not free,” said one, written at a university in Braamfontein in Johannesburg.

“If everybody doesn’t strive to bring the dream of a truly free and progressive South Africa to life, then that dream dies with Mandela,” added another.

“So many of his dreams remain unfulfilled by his comrades,” said a third.

“We encourage discourse,” said Foundation spokesman Morongwa Phukubye. “We debate his legacy. His legacy isn’t one of a saint.”

Harris said foundation representatives who go to South African townships and schools pick up varied reactions.

“We encounter narratives like ‘Mandela was a sellout and that’s why we’re in so much trouble today’,” said Harris.

‘Sellout’ or saint

Or, it can be “Madiba was a great leader and it’s a pity that his successors have been so poor.’ ‘If only Madiba had been younger when he came out of prison, maybe we wouldn’t have gotten to the mess that we have.’”

Harris took part in the truth and reconciliation commission created to look into the worst apartheid human rights violations.

He started working on Mandela’s papers in 2001, and over the years became close to the figurehead and his work on the Memory Center that is now the foundation headquarters.

Harris said he felt “deeply ambivalent” about the anniversary.

“On the one hand, I remember so strongly in the last five years of his life, thinking I just wish he would let go because I could see his life was becoming a burden to him.

“It’s a hard thing to say, almost a relief. But on the other hand, I still feel not really nostalgia, it’s more inspiration.”

Harris said the most important lesson he learned from Mandela is that “hope is not enough.”

“We need a deep belief that even if the future is worse than the present we still have to keep fighting, keep doing what needs to be done. So you endure. That keeps me going a lot.”