History is a jealous lover
One of my plans in retirement is to take up law. I do not intend to stress myself out reviewing for the bar; rather, I want to add to my skill set as a historian because history and law are allied disciplines—both deal with and argue from evidence. However, former Supreme Court Associate Justice Adolfo Azcuna rained on my plans, warning that “history is a jealous lover.”
My interest in law and legal documents stretches back to my undergraduate years. I stumbled across stray copies of ”Philippine Reports” in the Recto Avenue secondhand bookstalls. I bought the first three volumes because of their beautiful leather binding, and only later discovered that these contained Supreme Court decisions from the early years of the United States colonial period (1901–1903). I was first drawn to cases on banditry, bandolerismo, brigandage, and insurrection without appreciating these as legitimate challenges to the colonial order. Later, after learning about the Philippine-American War, I recognized some of those convicted as bandits, insurrectos, and tulisanes not as criminals, but as patriots who fought for Philippine nationalism and independence.
I focused on disputes regarding estates and inheritance, as these revealed the underside of Manila’s 400. A lot of social history—or even “sosyal history”—is documented in these legal records. I often recommend “Philippine Reports” as a primary source for those who write fiction to spare them from inventing plots and twists for their short stories and novels. To date, “Philippine Reports” is fast approaching Volume 1,000, bringing legal history from 1901 all the way to 2026.
Aside from “Philippine Reports,” much society gossip and genealogy can be had from the National Archives of the Philippines in bundles of old documents labeled “Bienes de difuntos” (Decedents’ Estates). The late Martin “Sonny” Tinio and Luciano P.R. Santiago were the undisputed masters of this realm, connecting the documents to history, genealogy, and contemporary society. In one archival document transcribed, translated, and illustrated in the book “Philippine Ancestral Houses” (1810–1930), published by GCF Books in 1980, a grand house long gone is reconstructed by someone’s last will and testament that catalogued all the house materials, from its roof down to the last wooden beam and nail.
While browsing familysearch.org in search of genealogical material on the 19th-century Filipino painter Félix Resurrección Hidalgo, a notarial document from April 1917 turned up that listed the property of the artist, who died in Paris on March 13, 1913. Transferred to his mother, María Bárbara Padilla, was P4,974.62 in cash and two shares of stock in the La Germinal Tobacco and Cigarette Company worth P1,000. In the list of muebles were not furniture, but an inventory of paintings, as follows:
A large painting, (The Assassination of) Governor Bustamante (presently in the National Museum), valued then at P5,000, or about P4.2 million today. Of course, the size and historical importance of this painting put its value way beyond P4.2 million.
Two framed copies of the prize-winning “Barca de Aqueronte” (Charon’s Boat)—awarded medals at the 1887 Exposición de Filipinas in Madrid and the 1889 Paris Exposition—valued at P200 each. I presume these paintings are now in the National Museum and the Lopez Museum and Library. A boceto (study or sketch) of Aqueronte, valued at P50, also in the Lopez Museum, together with a framed dark portrait, Un Guerrero (The Warrior), valued at P200.
Other named paintings: a study for the 1892 painting “Invasion of Limahong,” valued at P50, and a study for the 1903 painting in the Philippine Assembly Marble Hall we know as “Per Pacem et Libertatem” (Through Peace and Liberty).
Hidalgo painted countless seascapes, or marinas, and the inventory lists: a large seascape with a frame (P200); two medium-sized seascapes (P300, or P150 each); a small seascape with a frame (P100); an even smaller or unframed seascape (P50); 11 sketches of marinas (P50 each); a sketch, “Marina con figuras” (Seascape with Figures, P50); and one seascape boceto (P100). He also did landscapes (paisajes) and landscapes with figures.
Aside from art was real estate, whose descriptions were not confined to the size and location of the property and its improvements, but also named adjacent properties and their owners. For example, an 869-square-meter property located at 609 Muelle de la Industria, corner Sevilla Street—on which a camarín of sturdy materials was built—was valued at P18,424.50. Neighbors were Manuel Earnshaw and Mrs. Enriqueta Wilks de Sisi. A 1,613-square-meter property at 312–314 Dulumbayan (now Rizal Avenue), Santa Cruz, valued at P37,410.50, was bounded on the left (when entered from Echague Street facing Carriedo Street) by the property of the photographer Manuel Arias Rodríguez. A warehouse at the back of the property facing the Estero Cegado was near a building of reinforced concrete owned by Messrs. Lack and Davis, tenants of a portion of Hidalgo’s property.
Boring legal documents do not just settle disputes; to the skillful historian they contain a reflection of a vanished world.
—————-
Comments are welcome at [email protected]
Ambeth is a Public Historian whose research covers 19th century Philippines: its art, culture, and the people who figure in the birth of the nation. Professor and former Chair, Department of History, Ateneo de Manila University, he writes a widely-read editorial page column for the Philippine Daily Inquirer, and has published over 30 books—the most recent being: Martial Law: Looking Back 15 (Anvil, 2021) and Yaman: History and Heritage in Philippine Money (Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, 2021).
