‘Just leave’ is not enough
Last month, a clip of broadcast journalist and United Nations Women National Goodwill Ambassador Karen Davila drew criticism online after she said that a woman who depends on her partner for money cannot be considered empowered. Many felt that her comments were an attack on the women who choose to stay at home.
I personally don’t agree with such a definitive statement. I believe a stay-at-home mother is an empowered woman if she knows that her caregiving is an invaluable contribution to the household, that her unpaid labor has real economic value, and that she deserves an equal say in how the household’s money is spent, along with equal access to those resources.
What that debate does bring up is how money can influence the power dynamics in a relationship. When discussing the subject of domestic abuse, physical and sexual violence are usually what come to mind. Less focus is given, however, to how money can be used to control a woman and limit her options. Research shows that many women in abusive marriages cite that they choose to endure the violence because they cannot afford to leave.
Taking away a woman’s ability to earn is one of the earliest ways an abusive partner can control and compromise their partner’s agency and independence. Similar to other forms of abuse, economic abuse may begin in subtle ways and then drastically progress over time. It often starts with the abuser “selling the idea” under the guise of love and care. The partner may say he can take care of everything so she can focus on their home life. And this may be an arrangement that they both want at first.
As she comes to rely on him financially, however, an abusive partner may begin to use money in more overt ways to control her. He might give her an allowance that is insufficient to cover household expenses and still insist that she account for every peso that she was given. After a fight, he might “punish” her by withholding money for basic needs like their child’s tuition. And when she tells him she wants to return to work, he might forbid her from pursuing employment or other personal development opportunities. Sociologist Evan Stark describes this as coercive control. Abusers use a web of tactics like financial control, isolation, gaslighting, and other forms of emotional and psychological abuse to regulate their partner’s daily life, eventually conditioning the victim to believe that they need their partner’s permission for every little decision they make.
Part of what makes financial abuse so insidious is that although it does not leave physical scars, it can leave lasting damage to a survivor’s quality of life. A partner may drain their joint account or take out loans in her name without her consent, compromising her access to credit. A woman who has been kept out of work for a long time needs money to find a place to live and provide for her children while trying to rebuild her career. The financial consequences of abuse can still severely restrict what she is able to do, even after she has left.
Under Republic Act No. 9262 (the Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children, or Anti-VAWC Act), economic abuse is a punishable form of violence. It covers deliberately withholding adequate financial support, preventing a woman from pursuing legitimate work, restricting access to money, or keeping her from using shared property. The law applies to acts committed not just by a current or former spouse, but also by a dating/sexual partner or the father of a common child even after the relationship has ended.
Victims of economic abuse can apply to court for a protection order. As part of that order, the court can also direct the respondent to provide financial support if she or her child is legally entitled to it. And while protection orders at the barangay level only cover acts or threats of physical harm, they are still required to assist VAWC victims of economic abuse by referring cases to legal or social welfare services or other accredited organizations for assistance.
This issue is particularly close to my heart because of the stories I encounter in the communities I work with. One that comes to mind is Mila’s. For a long time, she secretly endured abuse from her live-in partner whenever he was drunk. After joining our livelihood training program, Mila got a job at our cafeteria social enterprise where she helped prepare lunch and snacks while her son was in school. She later told me that the arrangement allowed her to work without her partner knowing. Once she saved enough money to rent a house, she finally had the resources and confidence to leave.
“Just leave” is advice that many women in abusive relationships often hear from friends and loved ones. As the Philippines’ 18-Day Campaign to End Violence Against Women begins on Nov. 25, I hope we pay more attention to the practical support a woman needs to break free from abuse. It could be a safe place to stay, childcare assistance, or a small loan to help her slowly rebuild her life. Instead of asking why a woman stayed, the better question we should focus on is what she needs to leave safely, and which part of that we can help with.
—————-
******
Get real-time news updates: inqnews.net/inqviber




