Warning: Are you being played at this year’s planning session?
(First of two parts)
When an owner asks me what mindset to bring into an annual planning session, my answer is blunt, “Prepare for the biggest BS day of your life!”
You can have good people around that table and still come away with a thoroughly misleading picture of your business. Here are the signals I’d watch for.
I was in Hong Kong recently, speaking to a group of business owners and CEOs about annual planning. I described what happens when a division head misses the annual target and has to face the owner at the next planning session. Out comes last year’s PowerPoint. The illustrations get an update, the slides change order, and the target that was supposed to be reached by this December quietly acquires another 12 months.
After the speech, a man came up to me. “Tom, that’s exactly what’s happened to us,” he said. “How can you help me make this year’s planning session better?”
He became a client. My team and I facilitate these sessions, and he had just put his finger on one of the hardest parts of chairing your own.
From the audience, he recognized the maneuver immediately. At the head of the table, it looks different.
You have six presentations to get through. The person holding the clicker knows the business unit better than you do. And you quite reasonably want to spend your time on the year ahead. All three things work in the presenter’s favor.
Who brought last year’s plan?
The first signal comes before anybody has had a chance to bore you. The opening slide is already about next year. Stop there. Ask the presenter to pull up the plan you approved a year ago. Better yet, print it out beforehand and keep it in front of you. It is remarkable how much sharper your questions get when you can put a finger on the original promise.
Take each major commitment in turn. What did we say we would accomplish? What did we actually deliver? If the year is still under way, show the result to date and identify how much of the December figure is still a forecast. A sale you expect to close next month can do a surprising amount of work in a November presentation.
Now comes the part that most teams skip. What did we assume when we made that commitment? Which trends did we expect to affect our customers, our industry and our business over the year? Which materialized? Where were we right about the direction but wrong about the timing or the size of the impact? What evidence did we have then, what did we miss, and what will we do differently because of it?
The real biggie: Assumptions and trends
If the assumptions were never written down, say so. Give people a few minutes to reconstruct what they believed at the time and check what they remember against the evidence they used.
An old customer email can be worth more here than the confident recollection of the most senior person in the room.
Do this for a target you beat, too. An unexpected order that rescued your year could tempt you to spend money expanding a sales operation whose weaknesses are still there.
I care more about this discussion than I do about the number on the last slide. The quality of the assumptions and the trend analysis determines how much faith you can put in every number that follows. If a team repeatedly misses its targets and nobody examines how it arrived at them, the planning process itself deserves a place on the agenda.

A missed target gets a new deadline
The second signal is easier to spot with both presentations open. Read last year’s proposed action and this year’s aloud, without the illustrations. Suppose the old slide said “appoint three distributors” and the new one promises to “expand our network of channel partners.” How many distributors signed? If the answer is zero, what happened the last time you sat across from a distributor and asked for a signature?
That question might uncover something worth another year’s investment. Perhaps the distributors wanted a service commitment your company couldn’t make. If operations can now provide that service at a price that leaves you a profit, there’s a reason to give the distributors another call. If nobody has even spoken to a distributor since the first rejection, you have a reason to keep your checkbook closed.
The ambition can survive the audit. The team owes you an explanation of what makes it achievable this time.
The magic trick: Watch where the clicker takes you
The third signal is a little magic trick. A presenter whose business unit missed its target takes you through several slides about the one division that had a terrific year. The growth is real. So is the customer testimonial.
By the time you have congratulated the team and asked a couple of questions, everyone’s attention is wearing thin. The presenter advances to next year’s budget. Did you ever find out how the whole unit performed?
Try this the next time someone takes you on that detour. Congratulate the people who earned it. Then ask, “How much did that success contribute to the result you promised us? Where did we lose the rest?”
You may discover a practice worth copying across the group. You may also discover that the celebrated division is too small to make much difference to the total. Either answer gets you back to the business you came to discuss.
Sleight of hand
Sometimes, the miss is acknowledged and the sleight of hand comes in the explanation. “The economy.” “Structural shifts in our sector.”
Which economy? Which shift? Take me through one order we expected to win. Did the customer cancel the project, postpone the purchase or buy from a competitor? Those are three different outcomes calling for three different decisions. A proper root cause analysis gets specific enough to change a decision within your control.
Consider the incentives in that room. An executive who says, “We missed and I honestly don’t know why,” risks a reprimand, ridicule or even a job. Blaming the world economy is a much safer way to get through the afternoon.
As the owner, you have a say in which of those two answers you’ll hear next year.
Give the honest executive time to investigate, agree on the evidence you expect and set a date to hear the answer. How you handle those few uncomfortable minutes will be remembered long after the slides are forgotten.
Next week, we’ll put the proposed plan itself to the test. I’ll share the question I’d ask before approving next year’s budget.
Your three to thrive
1. Bring the original plan. Choose one commitment and trace it from last year’s target through the actual result to the assumptions and trends that shaped it. Ask which lesson changed this year’s proposal.
2. Read the old and new promises aloud. When a missed target reappears, have the presenter name the obstacle that stopped the first attempt and show what has changed enough to justify another.
3. Follow the money past the best slide. Put the standout division’s contribution beside the result for the whole unit. Keep asking why until the answer identifies a decision someone in your company can make.
(To be continued)
Tom Oliver, a “global management guru” (Bloomberg), is the chair of The Tom Oliver Group, the trusted advisor and counselor to many of the world’s most influential family businesses, medium-sized enterprises, market leaders and global conglomerates. For more information and inquiries: TomOliverGroup.com or email [email protected].
******
Get real-time news updates: inqnews.net/inqviber
Tom Oliver, a “global management guru” (Bloomberg), is the chair of The Tom Oliver Group, the trusted advisor and counselor to many of the world’s most influential family businesses, medium-sized enterprises, market leaders and global conglomerates. For more information and inquiries: www.TomOliverGroup.com or email [email protected].




