Faulty analogies (2)
It seems that Sen. Robinhood Padilla’s penchant for faulty comparison of himself to other notable past personalities like what we mentioned last week has rubbed off on other members of the Senate, among his minority allies.
Last week’s sessions of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial showcased once again the contrived histrionics of Sen. Pia Cayetano, known for her lachrymose display during the commotion in the Senate that now goes down as unprecedented in the history of that erstwhile august body. This was when Sen. Ronald “Bato” dela Rosa suddenly appeared after months of hiding to evade a possible arrest warrant from the International Criminal Court. Together with his patron, former President Rodrigo Duterte, Dela Rosa is charged as a co-conspirator in government operations, codenamed “Tokhang,” that have killed thousands of individuals, including the elderly and children, some as young as 4 years old.
That was quite a historic event, made ludicrous after shots were fired from within the Senate’s premises, after which Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano declared quite passionately that “the Senate was under attack!” Subsequent inquiries into the incident proved that the gunshots were courtesy of the Senate’s security personnel, therefore presenting no solid evidence of the Senate being attacked.
In the latest series of impeachment sessions, both Cayetano siblings have largely been silent, especially when the defense presented their witnesses, all of whom are closely involved in both official and business-related concerns of both VP Sara and her spouse, Atty. Manases Carpio.
Then, the other day, Pia Cayetano suddenly broke her silence. It was when the prosecution lawyers grilled the witnesses about dubious expenses of Carpio amounting to more than P200,000 for a meal at a high-end restaurant in Ginza, Tokyo and another quarter of a million pesos worth of sneakers for basketball players that the VP’s spouse is supporting.
Pia Cayetano burst almost into tears, claiming that it is a disdainful act to attribute to Carpio acts of generosity in paying for the shoes of 11 young athletes and of their parents and guardians. She repeatedly said, “I cannot hide my disdain, I cannot…”
She then rattled off her own acts of generosity, citing how she purchased sports gear and shoes for the classmates of her daughter at the University of the Philippines, and argued that law-abiding citizens who have the means to support struggling athletes should not be called out for doing so. She compared Carpio’s behavior to that of a loving parent who should not relinquish his duty to support others just because his spouse is a government official. She rattled off that such acts promote “character, leadership and teamwork” among young athletes, which are quite commendable.
Prosecutor Reynaldo Robles clarified that the questions on such huge financial transactions of the spouse of an impeached official are to examine whether the expenses align with constitutional standards requiring public officials and their families to “live modestly.” He noted that he had no issue with supporting sports per se, but rather with how public funds or wealth are being spent, or whether the source of the funds for the huge financial transactions is part of what can be considered “public.”
Not to be outdone in terms of getting the public’s attention, Padilla once again made himself the center of the conversation in the impeachment trial. Perhaps he has not moved on from enjoying star billing in his movies in the past.
He suddenly brought up his own brand of generosity and dared the prosecution to investigate his “expenses” in doing all his charitable acts.
It is interesting that two personalities—Pia Cayetano and Padilla—in the Senate impeachment court have displayed a common penchant for deflecting the attention of their fellow senator-judges and the prosecution to their own brand of leadership and of generosity.
What makes their acts of displaying such behavior noteworthy is the way they compare a high government official’s spouse’s gestures of generosity to those of just being a “loving parent” who wants to instill positive values of building “character, leadership, and teamwork.”
But such acts of displaying wealth through huge purchases of more than a quarter of a million pesos are manifestations of profligate spending rather than being attributed to “generous and loving parents.”
If indeed they are truly generous, they could have spent their extra millions on feeding the poorest of the poor, the homeless, and those who have to scrape every centavo just to live on.
Acts of ostentatious display of wealth to benefit a few people come off as typical arrogance of wealthy political patrons, who extract blind loyalty from their beneficiaries.
—————-
Comments to [email protected]
