AI to reshape banking landscape, challenge customer loyalty
Artificial intelligence (AI) is poised to reshape how banks compete for customers and defend their market positions over the next five years, according to Bain & Company.
In its “Future of Banking” report, the consultancy argues that AI is more than just a tool for boosting productivity. It could also help banks strengthen their market positions by allowing them to develop products and services that attract customers and win market share faster.
The stakes are high for both established lenders seeking to protect their dominance and challengers—like digital banks—looking to gain ground. Bain noted that return on equity (ROE) at the world’s largest banks has yet to recover to levels seen before the global financial crisis.
And market leadership makes a difference. Among the world’s 30 largest banks by assets at the end of 2025, those holding the top spot or a close second place in their respective business lines posted an average ROE of 15 percent, compared with just 9 percent for those with weaker market positions.
Against this backdrop, using AI to build or defend market leadership will be crucial to restoring bank returns, Bain says. One way the technology could change the competitive landscape is by making it easier for customers to move their money and banking relationships elsewhere.
AI-powered agents, for instance, can already monitor deposit rates, identify higher-yielding accounts, help customers transfer funds, redirect payroll deposits and move recurring bill payments. As these tools become more capable, switching banks could become much less of a hassle for depositors.
That could weaken some of the traditional advantages that have helped traditional banks retain customers, including their physical branches, brand recognition, customer relationships, trust and bundled services.
“Many traditional banking advantages—physical footprint, brand, customer primacy, trust and product integration—work because they help keep customers in place,” the report says.
“AI agents could change that equation. If comparing offers, identifying better terms or switching providers becomes dramatically easier, businesses that benefit from customers staying put could become more vulnerable,” it adds.
The technology also offers banks an opportunity to trim operating costs. Lenders are racing to adopt AI to improve efficiency, with potential implications for expenses, cost-to-income ratios and customer experience.
But lower costs may not necessarily translate into higher profits. As more banks adopt similar technologies and compete in markets with excess capacity and comparable products, efficiency gains could eventually be passed on to customers through lower prices or better offerings.
To capture more lasting value from AI, banks will therefore need to reinvest some of those savings in products and services that set them apart from competitors, Bain says.
“Those that do so early could take share from traditional competitors and compound that advantage over time,” the consultancy says.
Overall, Bain believes the AI-enabled customer cuts both ways for banks.
“The opportunity to further personalize offerings and enable customers is real, but so is the threat of deposit churn and customer defection,” the firm says. “A far larger contestable market than before means yesterday’s incumbent strategy won’t be defensible today.”
“Leadership in chosen markets, with a winning proposition with chosen customer segments, will matter more than ever,” it adds.




